Why Integrating Psychologists in Tech Design is Essential
Written on
Chapter 1: The Impact of Technology on Human Behavior
Technology has significantly influenced our thoughts, feelings, and actions. For many, the first and last tasks of the day involve checking their phones, with constant notifications and vibrations distracting us throughout. Devices like smartphones and computers facilitate not only work-related meetings via platforms like Zoom but also personal gatherings, from celebrations to somber events.
Moreover, our experiences on social media can temporarily alter our emotions and even affect our self-perception. Technology shapes our choices, influencing everything from our shopping habits (e.g., the convenience of Uber may dissuade car purchases) to our political views (e.g., algorithms on YouTube have been known to radicalize users).
Despite this profound impact, many tech products are created primarily by professionals without a background in psychology, whose roles often do not incorporate insights from psychological science. While a significant number of employees in major tech firms hold titles that include "scientist," the representation of behavioral specialists remains remarkably low, with only about 1% of these roles referencing behavior or behavioral science.
Given the scale at which technology influences human behavior and the accompanying profits from such changes, it raises the question: why do so few tech companies employ psychologists in significant roles during product development?
Understanding the Need for Psychological Expertise
The lack of psychologists in tech roles can be attributed to a weak pipeline from academia to industry. Historically, tech firms focused on enterprise solutions and hardware, favoring computer scientists over those trained in psychology. This trend continues today, with computer and computational sciences being the most popular academic paths for employees at companies like Google, where psychology ranks much lower.
This educational disparity may contribute to the underrepresentation of psychologists in leadership positions, leading to a lack of recognition for the potential contributions of psychological science in technology development.
Common Misconceptions about Psychological Science
Many technologists rely on folk psychology—the innate ability to understand and predict others' behaviors—when creating products. While this skill is beneficial in everyday scenarios, it can lead to a false sense of understanding human behavior. This overconfidence can result in flawed assumptions about how users will interact with technology.
Although user researchers examine consumer behavior, their findings often rehash established insights from academic psychology rather than build upon them.
Translating Psychological Insights to Product Design
Most tech professionals lack formal training in psychology, leading to gaps in their knowledge of relevant research. Even when they are aware of psychological studies, applying these findings to tech design is often complex. Human psychology is multifaceted, making it challenging to conduct rigorous experiments that yield universally applicable insights.
While academic psychologists conduct valuable research, their laboratory findings do not always translate seamlessly into real-world applications. The generalizability of these findings varies, complicating their use in product design.
Data-Driven Models vs. Psychological Insights
With the rise of machine learning, tech companies can predict human behavior based on data without necessarily leveraging psychological principles. However, this approach sacrifices clarity and applicability across different contexts. A model developed to predict one behavior may not work for another, highlighting the need for a deeper understanding of the psychological factors that drive user decisions.
Potential Advantages of Integrating Psychologists
Most consumer tech aims to influence user behavior, and integrating psychologists into development teams could yield significant benefits.
Accelerated Learning
Psychologists possess a wealth of knowledge accrued over a century of research, offering a substantial advantage in product development. Rather than starting from scratch, tech teams could build on established psychological principles.
Enhanced Design Principles
As technology becomes increasingly complex, the need for informed design principles grows. Psychologists can contribute to the creation of online communities that foster positive engagement while mitigating negative behaviors.
Minimizing Unintended Harm
While tech companies often aim to promote positive change, they may overlook the realistic limits of human behavior. By incorporating psychologists into product teams, companies can design with a more nuanced understanding of user capabilities, thereby reducing potential negative impacts.