The Enigma of the Great Library of Alexandria's Destruction
Written on
Chapter 1: The Great Library of Alexandria
The Great Library of Alexandria stood as a pivotal institution of knowledge in the ancient world. Its destruction raises profound questions about the loss of wisdom that occurred. Who could be responsible for its ruin? Was it a fire, invading forces, or zealots opposed to enlightenment? Perhaps it was a combination of these factors. Surprisingly, the library's decline wasn't a singular event; it faced numerous threats over time.
Identifying the culprits of the library's demise is challenging. Historical records point to three main suspects: Julius Caesar, Theophilus, and Caliph Omar. Let’s delve into the actions of these figures to uncover the truth.
Before we investigate these individuals, it's essential to understand the significance of this ancient repository of knowledge. Commissioned by Ptolemy II, who ruled from 285 BC to 246 BC, the library once contained around 400,000 scrolls. Ships entering the port of Alexandria were required to surrender their documents to city officials, allowing scribes to make copies for the library. An associated institution, the Serapeum, also housed numerous texts. A significant fire is often cited as a primary cause of the library's destruction.
Section 1.1: Julius Caesar and the Flames
Julius Caesar's account of the Roman Civil War (49 BC to 45 BC) hints at a destructive fire in Alexandria during his time. He suggests that a large blaze occurred as he attempted to escape the city, yet he makes no mention of the library itself.
In 48 BCE, during a conflict with Pompey, Caesar found himself in Alexandria. When Egyptians sought to obstruct his ships, Caesar's forces set their vessels ablaze, potentially igniting a fire that spread to the library. However, some historians argue that the fire primarily damaged a warehouse filled with scrolls rather than the library's main structure. Roman historian Cassius Dio suggests that the library might have sustained damage but was restored shortly thereafter. Thus, while Caesar may have been involved, the extent of his responsibility remains debated.
How much was lost when the Library of Alexandria burned? - This video examines the scale of knowledge and history lost in the wake of the library's destruction.
Section 1.2: Theophilus and the Transformation
Theophilus, the patriarch of Alexandria, is another figure often linked to the library's decline. He was known for his aggressive stance against pagan institutions and is believed to have converted the Serapeum into a church. During this process, many texts were destroyed.
Tensions escalated under Theophilus's nephew, Cyril, who incited violence against the library following the execution of a Christian monk named Hierax. The renowned philosopher Hypatia, who was seen as an enemy by some Christians, faced brutal murder at this time. Historians consider her to be the last head librarian of the Great Library, and her death led to the exodus of many scholars, resulting in the library's eventual decay.
The boring truth about the Library of Alexandria - This video delves into lesser-known facts surrounding the library and its historical context.
Section 1.3: Caliph Omar and the Final Blow
Caliph Omar, who led the Muslim conquest of Alexandria in 640 AD, is also frequently mentioned in discussions about the library's fate. Reports suggest he ordered the destruction of the library, stating that its texts either contradicted the Quran or were redundant. Allegedly, his forces used the books as fuel for bathhouses, resulting in a significant loss of knowledge.
However, the earliest accounts of this event, such as those by Bishop Gregory Bar Hebraeus and Islamic scholar Al-Qifti, lack definitive evidence. They fail to clarify which specific library was targeted, leaving the exact nature of the destruction uncertain.
In conclusion, the truth about the Library of Alexandria’s destruction likely involves all three suspects. The process of its demise unfolded over centuries, highlighting a persistent fear of knowledge among those in power. Knowledge poses a threat to oppressive regimes, prompting them to target centers of learning.
As we reflect on this historical tragedy, we must remember the enduring power of knowledge and its ability to challenge the status quo. What are your thoughts on who may have been responsible for the destruction of the Library of Alexandria? Share your insights in the comments below.
Chapter 2: The Legacy of Knowledge
Many rulers have feared the power of knowledge, yet wise leaders understand that intellect often triumphs over brute force. A historical figure who epitomized this was Ashurbanipal, the Assyrian emperor who established the largest library prior to the Great Library of Alexandria.
For those interested in the fascinating history of Ashurbanipal’s library, read on.
References
Phillips, Heather (2010). “The Great Library of Alexandria?” Library Philosophy and Practice. University of Nebraska–Lincoln.
Watts, Edward J. (2017), Hypatia: The Life and Legend of an Ancient Philosopher, Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
El-Abbadi, Mostafa (1990), The Life and Fate of the Ancient Library of Alexandria (2nd, illustrated ed.), Unesco.
James Hannam: The Mysterious Fate of the Great Library of Alexandria.